All Rentals

Homes for Rent in Shelter Island, NY Between $3,000 and $5,100

(1 - 15 of 39)
  1. This 3 bedroom, 2 bath bungalow has an open floor plan with hardwood floors throughout the large living room with fireplace, waterview den with loft, formal dining room and eat-in-kitchen with pantry. There's a private patio, carport and large gar...
    M. Wein Realty, Inc. ·18 hours ago on LinkuRealty
  2. Just bring your bag to this off- season rental. Set on.66 acres, this newly renovated home features three bedroooms and two full bathrooms. The first floor has a bedroom a den and full bathroom along with a beautiful chefs kitchen that flows into ...
    Treacy Cotter Villante ·13 hours ago on RealtyWW
  3. Adorable 3+ bedroom overlooking Hook Pond with heated pool. South of the highway and a 2 min walk to the beach! Living room with fireplace, dining with sitting area, master bedroom suite with child's bedroom nearby, kitchen, additional bedroom and...
    6 days ago on FavoriteRent
  4. This is a magical house. It is surrounded by woods and a pond. It is a one minute walk to Dering Harbor where the sunsets are neon pink. Upstairs, a glass room that feels like a tree house. It can be used as an additional bedroom using the day bed...
    6 days ago on FavoriteRent
  5. Beautiful turn key 4 bd 2 ba waterfront beach home in sought after sandy beach road. Open the door and right onto the sugar sand beach. Stones throw to two restaurants or BBQ outback. Freshly updated and renovated and waiting for you to book a wee...
    Patrick Carpenter ·1 week ago on RealtyWW
  6. Year round 2 story unfurnished home in the village of Greenport for rent. There is an open floor plan with eat in kitchen and living room on the first floor. Two bedrooms and a bathroom on the second floor. Updated with new appliances, wood floori...
    Kenneth Poliwoda ·1 week ago on RealtyWW
  7. 2024 Rates $3, 500 Year Round, July $7, 500, August-LD $7, 500: Circa 1900 farm house abutting vineyard located in Mattituck-Cutchogue School District. This updated home features an eat-in kitchen, full bathroom, living room, home office and bedro...
    William Walters ·1 week ago on RealtyWW
  8. Bucolic, airy, and steps from Orient's Village lane and beaches. Perfect location. Revel in 2605 Orchard Street, Orient's grandeur and comfort, set against 15 acres of open meadows with stunning 180 degree tranquil views. This light and bright lar...
    Lori M Feilen ·2 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  9. Beautiful North Fork home within walking distance to the beach, as well as numerous vineyards, restaurants, and local shops. Upon entering this home, you will enjoy spacious living quarters full of natural light and comfortable furnishings. The pe...
    Byron Chenault ·2 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  10. Spacious 3 bedroom home with a large den/family room plus a study/office, in beautiful New Suffolk. Eat-In-Kitchen, dining area, living room with wood burning fireplace, lots of outdoor space, large deck/balcony off of the dining room and enclosed...
    Rita Rooney ·3 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  11. Not available for year round rent at this time. Newly renovated three bedroom, two bath bungalow just outside of popular Greenport Village.This house provides a sense of privacy and relaxation close to the beach. Located less than one mile away, t...
    Mackenzie A Needham ·3 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  12. Charming, well-maintained home located in the heart of Bridgehampton. The main house offers 3 bedrooms (including 1st floor primary w/en-suite bath), 2.5 baths, den/study, great room, updated kitchen, and screened porch. Outside, enjoy the separat...
    Ann Gegelys ·3 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  13. A very unique situation that you don't see every day here in East Hampton. The tenant will have the choice to rent for either year round or summer and can just have the main house or have both house and cottage. The main house consists of vaulted ...
    John Brady ·3 weeks ago on RealtyWW
  14. Charming cottage with screened in porch for summer enjoyment. Shaded private backyard. Backs up too Sachem Woods Preserve with walking trails. This 3 bedroom, 1 bath cottage with recent updates, is centrally located to shopping, beaches and ferrie...
    M. Wein Realty Inc. ·3 weeks ago on LinkuRealty
  15. Stylish and comfortable 4 bed 2.5 bath house between the Ocean and Main Street, the location is perfect and moments to everything. A 3 minute walk to Amagansett Square, 8 minute walk to Indian Wells Beach. South of the highway. An open floor plan ...
    Posted on FavoriteRent
Email Alerts

Subscribe to email alerts when new listings show up for this search

Sends email alerts to

SET LOCATION

city
country

(undo)Price

to

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

Pets Allowed

Square Feet

to

Refine By Keyword